From the Codex //013: The 5 Key Elements of High-Converting Content (And Why Your Posts Aren’t Selling Yet)
Content strategy, brand archetypes, and buyer psychology decoded weekly to help you create a brand that resonates and converts. Never miss a release. Get my two most-read signature newsletters, "From the Codex and "Behind the Laptop," delivered straight to your inbox, filled with strategy, stories, and leadership insights so you can build a brand you’re wildly in love with and one your audience can’t stop talking about. [Join here]
The main reason your content isn’t converting isn’t because you need more followers, better visibility, or even more consistency. It’s because your content isn’t persuasive.
Most entrepreneurs fall into two traps:
They pump out “feel-good” posts that get likes but don’t move anyone closer to buying.
Or they overload their feed with pure value (tips, how-tos, and stories), but never connect the dots to why someone should invest.
Both have their place, but without persuasive content, you’re either entertaining your audience or educating, not leading and selling.
Over the past few weeks, I’ve broken down my Brand Demand Framework to help you build a content strategy that actually converts, using your brand archetype. If you missed it, start with:
Now, let’s go deeper into the bare bones of persuasive content: the elements that make a piece of content high-converting, magnetic, and impossible to scroll past.
Why Most Content Doesn’t Convert
The “Feel Good” Trap: Fluffy Engagement Posts
This is the type of content that makes your audience smile or hit “like,” but doesn’t drive them toward transformation or demonstrate any leadership. Think quick quotes, relatable memes, or casual check-ins. Fun? Yes. High-reach/High-Engagement? Most of the time. Profitable? Not on their own.
The “Value Overload” Trap: Teaching Without Persuasion
This is the opposite extreme. You’re teaching, storytelling, giving away everything you know, but not actually guiding people to take action or positioning yourself as a leader within your industry. You leave your audience informed by providing “value,” but you’re not guiding them through transformation and giving them a runway to actually buy from you.
There’s nothing wrong with either type of content, in fact, they’re essential to your overall marketing strategy. But if you remember from my Brand Demand Framework, you also need authority content and sales content (aka: persuasive content) to bridge the gap. Without it, sales will be low, no matter how big your audience is or what you’re selling.
The 3 Core Content Types You Need to Balance
Engagement Content
Builds community and trust. This is where you create connection and relatability. The intention here is to increase your reach, and create that first connection with your audience.
Value Content
Demonstrates your expertise and gives your audience practical insight in relationship to your zone of genius. This is where you connect the dots between “here I am” and “this is what I do/what I want you to know me for.”
Persuasive Content
Bridges the gap between your audience’s pain, their desires, and your offer. This is the type of content that drives sales. This is the content that connects “I know what your problems are and what the solutions are,” and “this is why you should trust what I do and how it will help you have what you want.”
👉 If you’re not sure how to balance these, read: How to Create Your Content Strategy Using Your Archetype.
The Elements of High-Converting Persuasive Content
I know the first thing you want to do when you sit down to create content is open your Notes app or pull up your Notion calendar. But before you even touch a blank page, there are a few foundational elements you need to know like the back of your hand.
These are what make sure you’re writing to the right person, saying the right thing, and giving them the information they’re actually ready to hear.
Because here’s the trap most entrepreneurs fall into: they “start creating content” and end up writing a lot of words… that don’t actually say anything. Or worse, you look back two hours later and can’t even tell what your point was, who you were speaking to, or why it matters.
That’s why I’ve created a checklist of the 5 elements every piece of persuasive content needs. Come back to these whenever you sit down to write, and you’ll always know your content is designed to convert.
P.s. if you want to dive deeper into creating content that converts, check out my $27 course, Content to Cashflow.
1. The Who
You need to know exactly who your content is for, and not just in a surface-level way. It’s not enough to say “female entrepreneurs.” That’s too broad. You need to refine it down until you can picture the person on the other side of the screen and speak directly to their current experience.
For example:
Generic Who: Female entrepreneurs.
Refined Who: Female entrepreneurs in their 30s, without kids, who want to create a personal brand on YouTube.
See the difference? The first one could apply to thousands of people. The second one is a person you can actually write for. You can understand her struggles (balancing ambition with lifestyle freedom), her desires (building influence and income through YouTube), and her buying psychology (she’s looking for mentorship that feels strategic but also values her individuality).
When you write with that level of clarity, your content stops sounding like “internet advice” and starts sounding like it was written just for them. That’s what pulls someone in, keeps them reading, and primes them to buy because now, they see you as the leader for them, not just some random person on the internet giving everyone advice.
2. The Symptoms
This is about understanding what exactly is going on in their life right now, the lived reality that proves to them, things aren’t working. Most people stop at writing generic insights or metaphorical symptoms (“you feel stuck,” “you’re playing small”). Again, that’s far too vague.
What you need are tangible, specific symptoms that make your person nod along thinking “wow, she gets me,” because they feel seen and you’re demonstrating you know exactly who they are and what they are going for.
For example:
Generic Symptom: You’re not making enough money.
Refined Symptom: You’re running every part of your business yourself. Managing your calendar, editing the videos, posting on social media. While you’re making just enough to stay afloat, you can’t afford to hire the support you actually need. What you really want is to focus on delivering your genius to clients, but the daily grind of trying to edit your own videos, post every single day on social media, and create your own emails each week leaves you no time to rest or spend time with your loved ones.
Again, can you see the difference? The first one states a problem. The second one describes their day-to-day reality using tangible symptoms. That’s what creates resonance and demonstrates you are an expert at what you do.
When your audience sees their actual lived experience mirrored back to them, they subconsciously link you to the solution. They don’t just think, “oh, she understands me.” They think, “she must know the way out.”
3. The Vision
This isn’t about your vision. It’s about theirs.
Your job is to articulate, with specificity, the future they already desire but probably haven’t had the courage to say out loud. It’s not enough to throw vague words like success or freedom on the page. What does success actually look like for your person?
Because here’s the truth: success is different depending on who you’re speaking to. For someone in their 20s, success might look like traveling the world, working from luxury Airbnbs, and documenting their journey over Michelin-star meals. For a parent in their 40s, success might mean building a team of ten, working ten hours a week, and having the freedom to be fully present at home while your team does the work for you.
When you paint that picture, aka their dream reality, you do two things:
You show them you actually understand who they are (and what they want)
You make their dream feel more real. When they can see themselves in the vision you describe, they’re more likely to believe they can achieve it and more likely to take action on the next step you’re offering.
This is one of the most underrated parts of persuasive content. Too often creators over emphasize the negative symptoms, and forget to paint the picture of their dream reality. The more vividly you can hold up the mirror to their highest self, the more powerfully they’ll move toward it.
4. The Offer
What makes your offer sell isn’t a list of features. It’s not about the number of calls, the length of the program, or the bonuses inside. Nobody cares about the details of what’s exactly included, they only care about is this actually for me, can this really solve my problems, and can this get me to where I want to be.
The only reason people care about the details of what’s included is after they’ve made the decision that they would like to buy.
Your offer is the bridge between where your clients are currently at now (aka: their symptoms) and where they want to be (their dream reality.)
For example:
If your audience is stuck running every part of their business alone, your offer isn’t “a 12-week program with coaching calls.” It’s the catalyst that gets them out of overwhelm and into a system where their team runs operations while they step into CEO-level leadership.
If your audience is tired of creating content that gets ignored, your offer isn’t “video editing support + strategy calls.” It’s the path that takes them from spinning their wheels never posting consistently to publishing content that builds authority, attracts clients, and actually converts.
When you position your offer this way, you stop selling logistics and start selling transformation. You make it clear that without your solution, they’ll stay stuck in the cycle they’re in and with it, they finally have the vehicle to step into their next chapter.
Your role here is to make that connection explicit: this is the missing link between where they are and where they want to be.
5. The Proof
Even the most magnetic message falls flat without credibility to back it up. Proof is what makes your audience believe you can deliver the transformation you’re promising.
But not all proof is created equal. Generic “my clients get results” isn’t enough. You need tangible, specific examples that reflect the symptoms and visions you’ve already outlined.
For example:
If your offer promises to help entrepreneurs scale their business, proof isn’t just “my client hit 6 figures.” It’s: “My client went from juggling every part of her business herself to hiring a team of three in under six months, freeing her to focus on her genius and doubling her income in the process.”
If your program helps with visibility, proof isn’t “my client grew online.” It’s: “After applying this strategy, she went from 200 YouTube subscribers to 5,000 in 90 days, and landed her first paid speaking opportunity.”
And here’s the deeper truth: part of being a respected expert in your industry is making sure you’re consistently collecting trackable metrics: in your client work, in your own business, and even in your audience growth.
Data is not just for spreadsheets; it’s the evidence that turns your story into a case study, your process into a framework, and your intuition into authority. If you want your influence to compound, you can’t just rely on “feel-good” wins. You need proof that scales with you.
You can use:
Client results: specific, outcome-focused transformations.
Testimonials: word-for-word reflections of the experience.
Case studies: before-and-after snapshots of the journey.
Your own story: the lived transformation that positions you as proof of concept.
The goal isn’t to overwhelm people with numbers and screenshots. It’s to create mirrors. When your audience sees themselves in your proof, they trust that your offer isn’t just theory, it works in the real world, and it can work for them too.
And here’s the thing: some of these elements might sound obvious. But surface-level understanding won’t move the needle. The difference between “kind of knowing” your client’s pain points and speaking to them with tangible specificity is the difference between content that gets scrolled past and content that sells out your offers.
If you want to go deeper into this, and avoid the costly mistakes most entrepreneurs make, check out my $27 course Content to Cashflow. Inside, I break down the biggest content mistakes keeping you stuck, plus the frameworks that consistently generate sales.
What Makes Persuasive Content Work (or Fail)
At the core, persuasive content really comes down to two things:
Tangibility and specificity. Vague = forgettable. When you describe your audience’s struggles and desires in detail, you stop sounding like “another coach” and start sounding like the person who gets them.
Connecting the dots. Every piece of content should trace a clear line from your audience’s pain → their dream → your authority and offer. Miss one step, and you’ll find yourself creating lots of high-engagement content with little to no conversions.
This is why persuasive content is the heartbeat of a content strategy for entrepreneurs, personal brands, and thought leaders who want to scale their influence and their sales.
Next Steps: Turn Content Into Cashflow
Persuasive content isn’t about hacks or trends, it’s about knowing exactly how to speak to your people, position your offer, and prove you can get results.
If you want to master this, here are your next steps:
Grab the Content to Cashflow course if you want the full breakdown of mistakes + frameworks.
Join Aesteria Academia if you prefer high-touch, hands-on support inside a private community of thought leaders and creators.
Explore these related articles:
Your content isn’t just here to fill a feed. It’s here to create cashflow, impact, and authority. Start with these five elements, and you’ll never wonder why your posts aren’t selling again.
That's a wrap on this week's article. From the Codex drops every Thursday; straight from my desk to yours. Join the list here so you never miss your next power move.
